1naresh2naresh
Array
(
    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity
            [type] => guest
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => Controlled
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege
                            [type] => privilege-set
                            [privilege-set] => GUEST
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => guest
                )

        )

    [55ce7664-2818-4d96-ac3a-28d7f42b394a] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => 55ce7664-2818-4d96-ac3a-28d7f42b394a
            [type] => toll-free-key
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => Controlled
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [acad8858-a287-4755-b384-f71af65f99f5] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => acad8858-a287-4755-b384-f71af65f99f5
                            [type] => toll-free-key
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => toll-free-key
                    [value] => tf_ipsecsha;d8a5dbc135b35d8f778182ddc1fbfa963e219c20
                )

        )

)
1naresh2naresh
Array
(
    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity
            [type] => guest
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => FreeToRead
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege
                            [type] => privilege-set
                            [privilege-set] => GUEST
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => guest
                )

        )

    [08df4e97-04af-4c11-b29a-2fa283bb0e71] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => 08df4e97-04af-4c11-b29a-2fa283bb0e71
            [type] => toll-free-key
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => FreeToRead
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [b443adb4-cd04-45ce-8532-da9f63a9bb58] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => b443adb4-cd04-45ce-8532-da9f63a9bb58
                            [type] => toll-free-key
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => toll-free-key
                    [value] => tf_ipsecsha;d8a5dbc135b35d8f778182ddc1fbfa963e219c20
                )

        )

)
1naresh2naresh
Array
(
    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity
            [type] => guest
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => FreeToRead
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege
                            [type] => privilege-set
                            [privilege-set] => GUEST
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => guest
                )

        )

    [3d61d8a4-ddc8-4c84-8316-0e37a9d220a2] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => 3d61d8a4-ddc8-4c84-8316-0e37a9d220a2
            [type] => toll-free-key
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => FreeToRead
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [802ba2ee-b254-4f48-ac2e-29478350088a] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => 802ba2ee-b254-4f48-ac2e-29478350088a
                            [type] => toll-free-key
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => toll-free-key
                    [value] => tf_ipsecsha;d8a5dbc135b35d8f778182ddc1fbfa963e219c20
                )

        )

)
1naresh2naresh
Array
(
    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity
            [type] => guest
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => Controlled
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege
                            [type] => privilege-set
                            [privilege-set] => GUEST
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => guest
                )

        )

    [55ce7664-2818-4d96-ac3a-28d7f42b394a] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => 55ce7664-2818-4d96-ac3a-28d7f42b394a
            [type] => toll-free-key
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => Controlled
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [acad8858-a287-4755-b384-f71af65f99f5] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => acad8858-a287-4755-b384-f71af65f99f5
                            [type] => toll-free-key
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => toll-free-key
                    [value] => tf_ipsecsha;d8a5dbc135b35d8f778182ddc1fbfa963e219c20
                )

        )

)
1naresh2naresh
Array
(
    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity
            [type] => guest
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => Controlled
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege
                            [type] => privilege-set
                            [privilege-set] => GUEST
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => guest
                )

        )

    [55ce7664-2818-4d96-ac3a-28d7f42b394a] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => 55ce7664-2818-4d96-ac3a-28d7f42b394a
            [type] => toll-free-key
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => Controlled
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [acad8858-a287-4755-b384-f71af65f99f5] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => acad8858-a287-4755-b384-f71af65f99f5
                            [type] => toll-free-key
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => toll-free-key
                    [value] => tf_ipsecsha;d8a5dbc135b35d8f778182ddc1fbfa963e219c20
                )

        )

)
1naresh2naresh
Array
(
    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity
            [type] => guest
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => Controlled
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege
                            [type] => privilege-set
                            [privilege-set] => GUEST
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => guest
                )

        )

    [55ce7664-2818-4d96-ac3a-28d7f42b394a] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => 55ce7664-2818-4d96-ac3a-28d7f42b394a
            [type] => toll-free-key
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => Controlled
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [acad8858-a287-4755-b384-f71af65f99f5] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => acad8858-a287-4755-b384-f71af65f99f5
                            [type] => toll-free-key
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => toll-free-key
                    [value] => tf_ipsecsha;d8a5dbc135b35d8f778182ddc1fbfa963e219c20
                )

        )

)
1naresh2naresh
Array
(
    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity
            [type] => guest
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => Controlled
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege
                            [type] => privilege-set
                            [privilege-set] => GUEST
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => guest
                )

        )

    [55ce7664-2818-4d96-ac3a-28d7f42b394a] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => 55ce7664-2818-4d96-ac3a-28d7f42b394a
            [type] => toll-free-key
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => Controlled
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [acad8858-a287-4755-b384-f71af65f99f5] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => acad8858-a287-4755-b384-f71af65f99f5
                            [type] => toll-free-key
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => toll-free-key
                    [value] => tf_ipsecsha;d8a5dbc135b35d8f778182ddc1fbfa963e219c20
                )

        )

)
1naresh2naresh
Array
(
    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:identity
            [type] => guest
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => FreeToRead
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => urn:ac.highwire.org:guest:privilege
                            [type] => privilege-set
                            [privilege-set] => GUEST
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => guest
                )

        )

    [b7a8993b-a55f-4e06-891d-24cd5c4e235e] => Array
        (
            [runtime-id] => b7a8993b-a55f-4e06-891d-24cd5c4e235e
            [type] => toll-free-key
            [service-id] => ajnr-ac.highwire.org
            [access-type] => FreeToRead
            [privilege] => Array
                (
                    [39eed6e0-6ccf-4a50-ac41-49b25e22c2fa] => Array
                        (
                            [runtime-id] => 39eed6e0-6ccf-4a50-ac41-49b25e22c2fa
                            [type] => toll-free-key
                        )

                )

            [credentials] => Array
                (
                    [method] => toll-free-key
                    [value] => tf_ipsecsha;d8a5dbc135b35d8f778182ddc1fbfa963e219c20
                )

        )

)


  
    










































































    Reply: | American Journal of Neuroradiology  
    



















    

































    
  
  




    
    

  

      


    

      

  
  
  

    

  

    

  

                
    

      

  

    

  
      
  
  

    


Advertisement



  



  


  
  



  



    

  


  


  


  
  
  
  
  
  

  	      


    
      

    
  
    
        
    

  

    
                        

  

                
    

      

	  

		
		

			

			  

  
      
  
  

    

  
  
      
Reply

  
      

  
      
Reply:
  
    	
S. Peschillo, D. Cannizzaro, E. Di Stasio, A. Caporlingua and P. Missori

  
    	
American Journal of Neuroradiology April 2016,  37 (4) E38; DOI: https://doi.org/10.3174/ajnr.A4732 

  
  
  



  


  
  



			

		

	
	
 	
	  
  

		
		

			

			  

  
      
  
  

    
  


  
  



  
      
  
  

    

  

    

  
      
  
  

    
We are grateful for the opportunity to answer questions from Yang et al.
We have analyzed each one of the critiques, and these are our comments to the numbered points below raised by the authors:
1) “It seems that the authors performed an integrative analysis of individual patients pooled from each individual study instead of a ‘meta-analysis.’”
We performed a comprehensive literature search in the PubMed and Scopus data bases on blister-like aneurysms. The aim of the work, as specified at the end of the introductory paragraph, was “to perform a systematic review and meta-analysis of the various types of treatment to compare their efficacy and safety.”
We have tried to do both and as described in the article, all included studies were noncomparative.
2) “If this is the case, did the authors exclude a study because it did not specify clinical presentation, method of treatment, or outcome?”
In the “Materials and Methods” section, we specified the exclusion criteria: “43 articles were excluded either because the patients did not have blister-like aneurysms or because the patients' presentations or angiographic outcomes were not described.” Therefore, we have included only patients with specific data regarding the clinical onset or with enough detail to obtain such information.
3) “The exact criteria used for study inclusion were not clear; this problem increases the potential for publication bias.”
In the third paragraph of “Materials and Methods,” we specified the following: 1) patient presentation described by using validated scales (Hunt and Hess [HH] and Fisher), 2) treatment technique (endovascular, surgical, combined), 3) long-term neurologic outcome (a good neurologic outcome was defined as a modified Rankin Scale score of 2). When an mRS score was not available, good neurologic outcome was determined from the description of the clinical results (eg, terms such as “no morbidity” or “good recovery”). We think that this is clear enough.
4) “A previous systematic review of 331 patients showed that results from multivariate analysis were influenced by the number of cases in a single study and the journal Impact Factor.”
We partially agree with this comment because some inadequate studies may hamper a good meta-analysis. Furthermore, another bias could be the definition of a blister-like aneurysm. Thus, in the article, we proposed a definition.
Our purpose was to offer a systematic review and meta-analysis of the various types of treatment of blister-like aneurysms on the basis of current literature. As we wrote in our article, further prospective studies are recommended to support our results.
5) “Second, for studies that did not provide information on HH or Fisher grade, did the authors assign their own scores as they did for modified Rankin Scale score? From our experience, assignment of these parameters on the basis of limited information reported in published articles can significantly bias the results.”
We have included studies that provided information on HH and Fisher grades, besides studies that described clinical and radiologic details that have allowed extraction of HH and Fisher grades. Studies that did not provide information (clinical and radiologic onset characteristics, HH or Fisher grades) have been excluded from the analysis.
We totally disagree with Yang et al that this can “significantly bias the results”; if the information is enough to extract the score (ie, a CT scan or a description of clinical status at admission), how this could alter the results?
6) “In addition, inclusion of both HH and Fisher grades simultaneously in the multivariate analysis may be inappropriate because they can provide similar information (ie, covariates).”
This is potentially true. However, multivariate analysis performed including the model, alternatively, HH or Fisher grades (with other variables) yielded similar results, thus confirming that both HH and Fisher grades are independent predictors of the clinical outcome in our study.
“In summary, the authors presented interesting results based on an integrative analysis of patients with blister-like aneurysms. Even though one acknowledges the inherent limitations of such analysis, the study can still benefit from better descriptions of the following: 1) inclusion criteria, 2) handling of missing data (eg, HH and Fisher grades, mRS), and 3) presentation of patients (SAH versus incidental).”
All these points were discussed above.
In conclusion, we hope that we have answered all the questions raised. We thank Yang et al for helping to clarify some important issues.
Probably this article has some limitations, and many times we have written that further prospective studies must be performed to confirm these results: “Larger and homogeneous cohorts of patients will help to elucidate the optimal treatment for patients with subarachnoid hemorrhage due to blister-like aneurysms” in the “Conclusions” paragraph.
Our article was reviewed by 2 independent reviewers and a Senior Editor from the American Journal of Neuroradiology, who are undisputed experts on this topic. The acceptance of the manuscript and publication in such an important journal confirmed the quality of our work.
Blood blister-like aneurysms are one my team's main fields of interest; we tried to do our best to add new elements to better understand these complex lesions.
  


  
  



  
      
  
  

    
  


  
  



  




  


  
  



  
      
  
  

    
  


  
  



  
      
  
  

     Back to top  


  
  



			

		

		
		

			

			  

  
        
In this issue

    
  
  

    
  


  
  



  
      
  
  

    

  

    

  
      
  
  

    


Advertisement



  



  


  
  



  



  


  
  



  
      
  
  

    

	  
  

		

          

            

  
      
  
  

     Print  


  
  



  
      
  
  

     Download PDF  


  
  



  
      
  
  

    
 Email Article
  


  
  



  
      
  
  

    
 Citation Tools
  


  
  



          

        

        
        

          

            



  
      
  
  

    

  

    

  
      
  
  

    

  
  
  
  
      
Reply:
  
    	
S. Peschillo, D. Cannizzaro, E. Di Stasio, A. Caporlingua, P. Missori

  
    	
American Journal of Neuroradiology Apr 2016, 37 (4) E38; DOI: 10.3174/ajnr.A4732 

  
  
  



  


  
  



  
      
  
  

    

  
    
  
  
    
  
  
    
  


  


  
  



  
      
  
  

    
del.icio.us logo Twitter logo Facebook logo Mendeley logo
  


  
  



  



  


  
  



  
      
  
  

    
  


  
  



          

        

	
 	
	
	


  


  
  



  
      
  
  

    
              Purchase  


  
  



  
        
Jump to section

    
  
  

    
  


  
  



  
      
  
  

    

  

    
 Related Articles
 Cited By...
  • No citing articles found.
 Similar Articles

  



  


  
  



			

		

	
	
 	
	
	


    

  



  

                
    

      

  

    

  
      
  
  

    


Advertisement